Statuses and lifecycle
Submission statuses
| Status | What it means | What moves it here |
|---|---|---|
| Draft | The author started the abstract but hasn't submitted it. Reviewers never see drafts. | The author presses Next on the first step of a new abstract. |
| Submitted | The author submitted it and no review has arrived yet. | The author presses Submit Abstract. |
| Under Review | At least one reviewer has submitted a review. | Happens automatically when the first review is submitted. |
| Accepted | The organizer accepted it. | Organizer decision. |
| Rejected | The organizer rejected it. | Organizer decision. |
| Waiting List | The organizer put it on the waiting list. | Organizer decision. |
Some details to be aware of:
- There's no way to withdraw a submitted abstract, and an abstract never goes back to Draft.
- Authors can delete an abstract only while it's a Draft.
- Drafts that are never submitted stay drafts forever. They can't be reviewed or decided, but organizers still see them in All submissions.
- The organizer can change a decision at any time, even after results are published.
Each person sees a different status
Organizers see the real status. Authors see a masked status until results are published.
| Real status | Organizer sees | Author sees before publishing | Author sees after publishing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Draft | Draft | Draft | Draft |
| Submitted | Submitted | Submitted | Submitted |
| Under Review | Under Review | Under Review | Under Review |
| Accepted | Accepted | Under Review | Accepted |
| Rejected | Rejected | Under Review | Rejected |
| Waiting List | Waiting List | Under Review | Waiting List |
Reviewers see their own review status instead: Pending (not reviewed by them yet) or Reviewed.
When an abstract can be edited
An author can edit and submit an abstract only when all of these are true:
- Its status is Draft or Submitted.
- The organizer has turned on Enable abstract submission form.
- Results have not been published.
- The current time is between the submission start date and end date, in the event's time zone. At the exact end time it's already closed.
So a submitted abstract locks as soon as the first reviewer submits a review, because it moves to Under Review. Locked abstracts show a lock icon and appear faded in My Submissions.
The topic and presentation type can never be changed once the draft exists.
When an abstract can be decided
The organizer can accept, reject or waitlist an abstract only when:
- it isn't a Draft, and
- every reviewer assigned to its topic has submitted a review.
If an organizer adds a new reviewer to a topic later, every abstract in that topic, including already-decided ones, gets a new pending review. Those abstracts can't be decided again until the new reviewer has reviewed them.
How the score is calculated
- Each reviewer gives one whole-number score from 1 to 10.
- The abstract's score is the simple average of all completed reviews, rounded to two decimals. Pending reviews don't count.
- No weighting or other scoring scales are available.